From Volume to Security: Issues Impacting eDiscovery Business Performance (2016-2024)

Editor’s Note: In the ever-evolving landscape of eDiscovery, professionals face a myriad of challenges that span technological, operational, and strategic domains. The eDiscovery Business Confidence survey series has consistently provided invaluable insights into these challenges, enabling industry leaders to navigate the complex terrain of digital data management, security, and legal compliance. Drawing on the comprehensive survey results between 2016 and 2024, this concise research report aims to distill key trends, identify persistent and emerging challenges, and offer actionable insights for industry stakeholders. By analyzing data from the latest quarters and across the entire survey period, the report highlights the dynamic interplay between technological advancements, regulatory demands, and the growing complexity of data. It is our hope that this report will serve as a valuable resource for eDiscovery professionals, guiding strategic decisions and operational improvements in the face of evolving industry challenges.

Background Note: The eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey is a well-established, quarterly research initiative designed to provide insights into the state of business confidence in the eDiscovery ecosystem. Since its inception, the survey has been administered 33 times, drawing approximately 100 respondents per survey and totaling 3,249 responses in aggregate. This consistent pulse check has played a pivotal role in understanding industry sentiment, capturing trends in revenue and profit, and identifying the key challenges faced by eDiscovery professionals.

Industry Report

From Volume to Security: Issues Impacting eDiscovery Business Performance (2016-2024)

ComplexDiscovery Staff

The field of eDiscovery stands at the intersection of technology, law, and business operations, continuously adapting to the rapid pace of digital transformation. As data volumes explode and new types of digital information emerge, eDiscovery professionals grapple with an array of challenges that impact the efficiency, cost, and effectiveness of legal discovery processes. From budgetary constraints to the increasing complexity of data, these challenges demand strategic responses and innovative solutions. This research report synthesizes findings from the “Issues Impacting Business Performance in eDiscovery” section of the survey series, offering a panoramic view of the industry’s evolving landscape. Through a meticulous analysis of the surveys conducted over the last two quarters and a comprehensive review of trends across the surveyed period, the report sheds light on the core challenges facing the eDiscovery sector. It also explores the underlying reasons for these challenges, providing industry leaders with the insights needed to forge ahead. As the eDiscovery industry continues to evolve, understanding these trends and challenges becomes paramount for developing resilient strategies and maintaining a competitive edge. This concise report aims to equip industry stakeholders with the knowledge to navigate the complexities of today’s eDiscovery challenges, fostering innovation and driving the industry forward.

Combined Analysis of Winter 2024 and Fall 2023 Results

The analysis of the Winter 2024 and Fall 2023 survey results reveals an intriguing landscape of evolving challenges within the eDiscovery industry. The issues most likely to impact business performance have been ordered based on the highest percentage reported in Winter 2024 for a clearer perspective on prioritizing challenges.

1. Increasing Types of Data (30% in Winter 2024): Despite a decrease from 37.50% in Fall 2023, this remains the most significant challenge, highlighting the complexity and diversity of data types organizations must manage.

2. Budgetary Constraints (23% in Winter 2024): This issue saw a slight increase from 21.88% in Fall 2023, reflecting ongoing concerns about financial resources allocated to eDiscovery processes.

3. Data Security (16% in Winter 2024): There was a notable increase from 3.13% in Fall 2023, possibly reflecting a renewed awareness or emerging challenges in protecting sensitive information.

4. Increasing Volumes of Data (16% in Winter 2024): This is a slight decrease from 20.31% in Fall 2023, yet it remains a significant concern, emphasizing issues related to the scalability of eDiscovery solutions.

5. Lack of Personnel (9% in Winter 2024): This issue saw a minor decrease from 10.94% in Fall 2023, continuing to indicate a need for more specialized expertise or staffing in the eDiscovery field.

6. Inadequate Technology (6% in Winter 2024): This was virtually unchanged from 6.25% in Fall 2023, underscoring persistent gaps in the technological tools available for eDiscovery processes.

Notable Changes and Observations

• The largest increase was observed in Data Security, jumping by 12.87 percentage points from Fall 2023 to Winter 2024, indicating a significant resurgence of concern in this area.
• Increasing Types of Data saw the most substantial decrease, dropping by 7.50 percentage points, though it remains the top concern, reflecting ongoing struggles with data diversity.
• Minor fluctuations in other areas, such as Budgetary Constraints and Lack of Personnel, suggest a relatively stable but still challenging environment for eDiscovery professionals.

Implications for Industry Professionals

This comparative analysis underscores the dynamic nature of challenges within the eDiscovery sector, with varying emphases on data complexity, security, and resource allocation. The notable rise in data security concerns warrants particular attention, suggesting either an increase in threats or heightened industry awareness. The persistent issues around data management and technological adequacy highlight the need for continuous innovation and strategic investment in both tools and talent. These trends provide critical insights for industry leaders, pointing to areas requiring focus, adaptation, and strategic planning to navigate the evolving landscape of eDiscovery challenges effectively. ​

Overview of Average Concerns Across All Surveys

Analyzing the complete set of survey results across all periods offers a comprehensive overview of the predominant challenges faced in the eDiscovery industry. This analysis reveals the average percentages for each area of concern, providing insights into the persistent and evolving challenges over time.

1. Budgetary Constraints (25.87%): This emerges as the most significant ongoing challenge, indicating a consistent concern across the industry regarding the financial resources allocated to eDiscovery processes.

2. Increasing Types of Data (20.64%): Reflecting the complexity and diversity of data types that organizations need to manage, this issue ranks as the second most significant challenge, underscoring the continuous evolution of data forms and sources.

3. Increasing Volumes of Data (20.39%): Closely following the challenge of data types, the issue of managing increasing volumes of data highlights the scalability and capacity challenges within eDiscovery solutions.

4. Lack of Personnel (13.73%): This indicates a significant concern about staffing shortages or the need for more specialized expertise within the eDiscovery field.

5. Data Security (12.18%): Although ranked lower on average, data security remains a crucial concern, reflecting apprehensions around protecting sensitive information against breaches and unauthorized access.

6. Inadequate Technology (7.16%): While the least cited concern on average, the mention of inadequate technology underscores a need for improved or more accessible eDiscovery tools to handle the complexities of modern data.

Implications for Industry Leaders

This comprehensive and concise analysis across all surveyed periods highlights the ongoing nature of challenges in the eDiscovery sector. The consistent prominence of budgetary constraints suggests an industry-wide struggle with the costs associated with advanced eDiscovery practices. Similarly, the complexities introduced by the increasing types and volumes of data necessitate ongoing innovation in eDiscovery tools and methodologies.

The concern over the lack of personnel points to a critical need for talent acquisition and development strategies, emphasizing the importance of cultivating skills in data management, cybersecurity, and legal technology. Despite being the least cited concern, the issue of inadequate technology highlights a gap between existing solutions and the evolving needs of the eDiscovery process, suggesting opportunities for technological advancement and innovation.

These insights underscore the importance of strategic planning and investment in technology, talent, and cybersecurity measures. By addressing these key areas, industry leaders can better navigate the challenges of managing ever-expanding and evolving data within the legal and regulatory frameworks, ensuring the continued effectiveness and efficiency of eDiscovery processes.

Considerations and Conclusion

As we conclude this comprehensive examination of the eDiscovery landscape, it is clear that the industry is at a critical juncture. Faced with ever-increasing data complexity, evolving security threats, and the continuous need for strategic investment in technology and talent, eDiscovery professionals are navigating an increasingly complex terrain. The findings from the “Issues Impacting Business Performance in eDiscovery” section of the survey series underscore the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead. In response, industry leaders must embrace innovation, foster collaboration, and invest in the development of solutions that address these persistent and emerging challenges.

Background Information: Survey Charts

(Charts Can Be Expanded for Detailed Viewing)

Chart 1: An Aggregate Overview of Issues Impacting eDiscovery Business Performance

Chart 2: An Overview of Issues Impacting eDiscovery Business Performance in the Winter of 2024

Chart 3: An Overview of the Percentage of Respondents Viewing Increasing Types of Data as the Top Issue Impacting eDiscovery Business

Chart 4: An Overview of the Percentage of Respondents Viewing Budgetary Constraints as the Top Issue Impacting eDiscovery Business

Chart 5: An Overview of the Percentage of Respondents Viewing Increasing Volumes of Data as the Top Issue Impacting eDiscovery Business

Chart 6: An Overview of the Percentage of Respondents Viewing Lack of Personnel as the Top Issue Impacting eDiscovery Business

Chart 7:  An Overview of the Percentage of Respondents Viewing Data Security as the Top Issue Impacting eDiscovery Business

Chart 8: An Overview of the Percentage of Respondents Viewing Inadequate Technology as the Top Issue Impacting eDiscovery Business

Chart 9: Survey Participant Overview (Aggregate)

Chart 10: Survey Participant Overview (Winter)

• eDiscovery Survey Archives of ComplexDiscovery
• eDisclosure Systems Buyers Guide – Online Knowledge Base