CLOC Announces 2nd Annual State of the Industry Survey Results

The 2019 CLOC State of the Industry survey includes respondents from more than 200 companies of different sizes representing over 30 industries and 18 countries. The second annual survey was developed by polling CLOC members during the first four months of 2019 about their 2018 results. The survey consisted of questions that were designed to provide a deeper understanding of legal operations expenditure, headcount, technology & innovation, and relationships with various legal services providers and law firms.

en flag
nl flag
fr flag
de flag
pt flag
es flag

Press Announcement from the Corporate Legal Operations Consortium (CLOC)

Corporate Legal Operations Consortium (CLOC) today [July 18, 2019] released the results of their 2nd Annual State of the Industry Survey which compared internal to external expenditure, legal operations headcount, technology and innovation, and Law Firm evaluations in its member companies.

The 2019 CLOC State of the Industry survey included respondents from 200+ companies of different sizes representing over 30 industries and 18 countries. According to the survey, corporate legal departments experienced growth in demand for legal services and continued to focus on various means to control costs. Many grew their legal operations teams and continued to invest in technology.

The sum of all external expenditure submitted by respondents totaled over $6.3B for the 200+ companies who participated in CLOC’s survey. Over 50% of respondents reported that their external expenditure on law firms either decreased or stayed the same from 2017 to 2018.

Quick Stats

  • $11.7M Median External Expenditure vs $13.5M Median Internal Expenditure
  • .46¢ of every $1 spent on legal costs goes to external legal costs
  • $290K – Median Internal Expenditure per Legal Department FTE
  • $451K – Median External Legal Expenditure per In-House Attorney

The average total legal spend as a percentage of revenues is 0.44%. Companies reported using a number of techniques to control their overall costs including leveraging alternative fee arrangements (AFAs), preferred provider panels, alternative legal service providers, and moving more work in house.

Legal Operations professionals are accounting for a larger portion of their departments as the function grows in scope and new roles are added. Of the companies that participated, 40% reported an increase in full-time attorney headcount in 2018 and 37% reported an increase in dedicated legal operations FTEs.

According to Jason Barnwell, Assistant General Counsel-Legal Business, Operations, and Strategy, Microsoft Corporation and CLOC Board Member, “The core challenge for most legal operations professionals typically reduces to effective change management. The hardest part of the job is helping the people you serve embrace the future you have to offer. Everything else is secondary to that. The great news is that this is a very transferable leadership skill that creates some fabulous options.”

Legal Operations functions continue to have a strong focus on technology to improve transparency and data analytics, efficiency, quality and consistency of work, and speed of execution. 72% of respondents reported having a technology roadmap. Companies with a developed technology roadmap spend 3x more on technology than organizations that don’t have a roadmap or those still developing a roadmap.

Mike Haven, Sr Directory, AGC and Head of Legal Operations, Gap, Inc. and CLOC Board Member urges caution in adopting new technology, “Workflow automation, robotic process automation and machine learning all are promising technologies that can and will be leveraged in the legal industry of the future. But cool technology sitting on top of bad process will not be helpful. Beware the bright, shiny objects!”

Implementation of technology solutions was fairly high for a number of tools, with more than 78% of respondents reporting the use of eBilling and 65% using a contract management solution. However, the contracts management market is quite fragmented with 30+ different vendors being used among the 112 companies with a system.

The majority of corporate legal departments do not have in-house engineering support, with only 35% of respondents reporting to have dedicated in-house engineering resources. Regardless, most companies rely on third-party technology solutions for their legal department needs and adoption of legal technology is increasing in companies of all sizes and industries. While the use of artificial intelligence in legal departments is still in early stages, many see its promise and are already starting to explore how best to leverage it. 45% of respondents are exploring the use of AI to reduce legal workload, gain more insight, or improve performance; however, only 12% are currently using AI within their tools and processes.

“This year’s data shows that the role and function of legal operations continues to grow,” shares CLOC’s President Mary O’Carroll, who also holds the role of Director Legal Operations at Google. “Technology is changing quickly and more legal operations departments are embracing solutions to improve productivity and results.”

About Corporate Legal Operations Consortium (CLOC)

CLOC is 501(c)6 non-profit professional association. CLOC’s mission is to help legal operations professionals and other core corporate legal industry players (e.g. tech providers, law firms, LPO’s, law schools, etc.) optimize the legal service delivery models needed to support the needs of small, medium and large legal departments.

Additional Reading

Source: ComplexDiscovery

Business as Unusual? Eighteen Observations on eDiscovery Business Confidence in the Summer of 2020

The results of the recent Summer 2020 eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey present the unfortunate and continuing impact of COVID-19 on the business of eDiscovery. However, for these pandemic-driven results to be fully understood, they should be viewed through the contextual lens of the results of all nineteen surveys that have been administered to eDiscovery professionals since the inception of the eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey in early 2016.



Check Out the Observations Now!

ComplexDiscovery combines original industry research with curated expert articles to create an informational resource that helps legal, business, and information technology professionals better understand the business and practice of data discovery and legal discovery.

All contributions are invested to support the development and distribution of ComplexDiscovery content. Contributors can make as many article contributions as they like, but will not be asked to register and pay until their contribution reaches $5.

HaystackID and NightOwl Global Merge

According to today's announcement, the NightOwl merger is HaystackID's fourth major...

Mitratech Acquires Tracker Corp

The acquisition supports Mitratech’s mission to provide legal and compliance solutions...

A Window into Malware? The New Malware Reverse Engineering Handbook from CCDCOE

According to Wikipedia, malware analysis is the study or process of...

Much Ado About Something? The Hype Cycle for Legal and Compliance Technologies (2020)

The information and insight highlighted by Marko Sillanpaa of Gartner in...

A Running List: Top 100+ eDiscovery Providers

Based on a compilation of research from analyst firms and industry...

The eDisclosure Systems Buyers Guide – 2020 Edition (Andrew Haslam)

Authored by industry expert Andrew Haslam, the eDisclosure Buyers Guide continues...

The Race to the Starting Line? Recent Secure Remote Review Announcements

Not all secure remote review offerings are equal as the apparent...

Enabling Remote eDiscovery? A Snapshot of DaaS

Desktop as a Service (DaaS) providers are becoming important contributors to...

Home or Away? New eDiscovery Collection Market Sizing and Pricing Considerations

One of the key home (onsite) or away (remote) decisions that...

Revisions and Decisions? New Considerations for eDiscovery Secure Remote Reviews

One of the key revision and decision areas that business, legal,...

A Macro Look at Past and Projected eDiscovery Market Size from 2012 to 2024

From a macro look at past estimations of eDiscovery market size...

An eDiscovery Market Size Mashup: 2019-2024 Worldwide Software and Services Overview

While the Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) for worldwide eDiscovery software...

Business as Unusual? Eighteen Observations on eDiscovery Business Confidence in the Summer of 2020

Based on the aggregate results of nineteen past eDiscovery Business Confidence...

A Growing Concern? Budgetary Constraints and the Business of eDiscovery

In the summer of 2020, 56% of respondents viewed budgetary constraints...

A Change in Tempo? eDiscovery Operational Metrics in the Summer of 2020

In the summer of 2020, 91 eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey participants...

Shifting Gears? eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey Results – Summer 2020

This is the nineteenth quarterly eDiscovery Business Confidence Survey conducted by...

HaystackID and NightOwl Global Merge

According to today's announcement, the NightOwl merger is HaystackID's fourth major...

Mitratech Acquires Tracker Corp

The acquisition supports Mitratech’s mission to provide legal and compliance solutions...

XDD Acquires LightSpeed Legal

According to David Moran, XDD President, and COO, “As we continue...

XDD Acquires RVM

According to XDD CEO Bob Polus, “Merging forces with RVM further...

Five Great Reads on eDiscovery for July 2020

From business confidence and operational metrics to data protection and privacy...

Five Great Reads on eDiscovery for June 2020

From collection market size updates to cloud outsourcing guidelines, the June...

Five Great Reads on eDiscovery for May 2020

From review market sizing revisions to pandemeconomic pricing, the May 2020...

Five Great Reads on eDiscovery for April 2020

From business confidence to the boom of Zoom, the April 2020...